Dean James has made 25 appearances in the Eredivisie this season, including playing 75 minutes against NAC Breda in March
A court in the Netherlands has dismissed a legal challenge by NAC Breda to replay a league fixture because of the ineligibility of an opposition player – avoiding more than 130 Eredivisie matches potentially being scrutinised.
NAC were contesting their 6-0 defeat against Go Ahead Eagles on 15 March, arguing that defender Dean James was ineligible to play after obtaining Indonesian citizenship in March 2025 in order to represent the Asian nation at international level.
Dual citizenship is restricted in the Netherlands, meaning players previously registered as Dutch nationals may become non-EU foreign players after switching allegiance, which would require them to obtain a work permit before resuming their professional career.
On Monday, a court in Utrecht sided with the Royal Dutch Football Association (KNVB) which had refused to approve a replay.
The KNVB argued that while James was technically ineligible, neither the club nor the authorities were aware of the implications of his nationality switch.
Had the decision gone in NAC's favour, the KNVB said more than 200 matches across the top two tiers of Dutch football could have been open to similar legal challenges, including 133 in the Eredivisie.
"It's never pleasant to find ourselves in court against one of our clubs. The court ruled that the league board acted diligently and in accordance with the applicable rules," KNVB told Reuters.
"NAC Breda raised an important issue, which we were fortunately able to resolve quickly through a great deal of joint effort. That is important for the present and for the future."
NAC Breda are 17th in the Eredivisie, six points from safety with two matches remaining.
Listen to the latest Football Daily podcast
Premier League: Nottm Forest 2-0 up at Chelsea as Palmer has penalty saved
World Snooker Championship final – Wu v Murphy
Antonelli steps up his level in dramatic fashion
Katniss Everdeen, played by Jennifer Lawrence, ignites a revolution
The rise and fall of London's most legendary gangsters
Critically-acclaimed romantic period drama starring Saoirse Ronan
Charming family favourite featuring the iconic Minions
What would it cost England and Scotland fans to go to World Cup?
Heartbroken Allen loses semi-final after fluffing winning pot. Video
Three red cards for hair pulling in 2026 – is it time to change law?
Arsenal beat Fulham to move six points clear of Man City. Video
The remarkable life of Zanardi, a 21st century hero who inspired millions
Are Ipswich better equipped for Premier League this time?
West Ham survival hopes take a blow after defeat to Brentford. Video
VAR, fine margins & 'superior' Lyon cost Arsenal Champions League final spot
Is Saudi Arabia's sports revolution unravelling?
Why was Mudryk given ban in secret and what happens now?
Hypnosis, Al Pacino and lies – how I tried to motivate my players
Sutton's predictions v Ella and Jake from Jamie Johnson FC
A golden period for snooker – but are UK clubs returning from doldrums?
How tragedy & 'a scary 5ft Asian' mum shaped rising UFC star Kavanagh
What now for Rahm, DeChambeau and LIV's biggest names?
'I lost myself' – Bright on retirement, abuse and the future
Lomu, Wilkinson, Pollock? Rugby's search for a crossover star
The 92mph England fast bowler ready to move on from difficult debut
Copyright © 2026 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read about our approach to external linking.
About the Author
